Life\’s Direction

Acer Aspire One vs HP 2133 Mininote

Posted in Uncategorized by lifesdirection on December 14, 2008

Introduction

I dont know quite who reads this blog but I had an abnormally high hit-rate yesterday when I posted some thoughts about the netbooks I own and have owned in the past, namely my previous HP 2133 and my current Acer Aspire One (Which I am currently using to write this post).

I dont typically write any sort of hardware or software reviews on my blog but there seems to be an interest out there from my readers, lets get on with it shall we?

The Machines

HP 2133 – The model I had was the highest available, the 160GB hard disk bluetooth and 6-cell battery all with 2 GB RAM. VIA 1.6 CPU

Acer Aspire One – Staples demo model, 8GB SSD, 512MB RAM Intel Atom

Cons

I will talk about each machines short comings first, keep in mind that I am bias, and I will focus mainly on Linux, though I did run Windows XP on the mininote for some time.

HP 2133

The stupid battery (6-cell)  made the machine awkard to use because the battery came in the way of opening the LCD to a reasonable angle, that was annoying, The hardware was not linux compatible.  While they (HP) was able to cludge together a SLED install (Suse Linux Enterprise Desktop) which sucks because its old, unusable and difficult to maintain, the hardware at best was hacked together, I couldn’t not get compiz to work well, I did spend time downloading and compiling the drivers of the via website (which apparently have now been open sourced, hopefully someone can fix them). The CPU was ok but it didn’t scale properly (In Linux as well). HP is a bunch of cheapos, they didn’t give a case with their netbook and up until recently they were non-existent, thats just cheap when I could get an ASUS EEE PC for dirt cheap and get a proper envelope for it.

Did I mention it came with Vista?  That was stupid, REALLY STUPID, Windows Vista requires at least 2GB RAM and a dual-core 2.5+ to run reasonably, instead they tried to cram it on an under-powered machine as the result was a phenominally slow boot time and slow response in general from the machine.  Speed increased greatly with Windows XP, but if you want to run Vista hey, “Dogs to their vommit like fools to their folly”.

Acer Aspire One

It could just be the model I have but the keyboard on this thing sucks, it has the ‘7’ shaped enter key that is non-standard so whenever I get to hitting enter it looks like this\.   Much mockery from my friends on IM.  Another con to this netbook is the battery life, its not bad but it only gives me 2.5 hours.

* A note about the Acer Aspire One is that it was just under 4x the price of my HP 2133, I got it for 250CAD.

The Pros

HP 2133

Best Keyboard on the market hands down, this thing is great! its like a whole new world compared the the Aspire One.  The case was built quite solid, definatly a good peice of workmanship.  The CPU was also quite snappy in Windows XP (my unit came with Vista).  I have read reviews of people complaining about the speed of the VIA CPU but I dont know why.  This machine is definatly a winner if you run Windows XP on it.

The display was also very very impressive, the resolution was nice and the glossy screen made a definite difference, also I noticed Apple copied HPs design display in their new line of notebooks.

Acer Aspire One

This unit is great for linux users, I immediately removed Linspire so I dont really have any comments towards it, I opted for a Ubuntu 8.10 install with netbook remix (see my previous post for links).  The hardware is on a different level with regards to compatibility, the only thing that currently requires proprietary drivers is the atheros chipset but they work well with Linux anyway and, have been recently released into the wild.  No thanks broadcom, I dont need your crap, not here 🙂

Physcially the machine is more durable, it scratches easy but because of its light weight its less likely to happen and I don’t have to worry about scratching an aluminum casing, and Acer gave me an envelope with the unit, that is revolutionary way way way way better than what HP did for me (nothing).  The machine is solid but light weight.

Conclusion

I like both, but for a linux user the Aspire was best for me, though If I could choose between the two I would choose neither, I would go for the HP 1000 Mininote, its the like te HP 2133 except the hardware is actually Linux Compatible (Atom based).

I hope this post has helped some of you who are looking for infromation on Ubuntu and either of these netbooks, feel free to comment I will respond to your comments as soon as I am able.

Advertisements

3 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Enrique said, on May 16, 2009 at 8:32 pm

    THANK YOU VERY MUCH, I’m planning on buying my GF a netbook for her birthday and I’ve been reading a lot of things aroud the web.

    I’m gonna buy her the HP2133 cuz she’s the kind of person that just needs a computer to use Office, check Myspace, MSN & things like that and that keyboard is one nice thing.

    Thanks for your review, cheers.

    • lifesdirection said, on May 17, 2009 at 6:33 am

      Hey Enrique,

      No problem. Just wanted to let you know you might want to check out the HP Mini 2140, the CPU is alot better, if you are in the states you cant get it with the HD resolution. Also the HP 1035 is good too but the build quality is not as nice, though the price is far better.

      • Enrique said, on May 17, 2009 at 7:09 pm

        Man that 2140 would be great but as I told you It’s for my GF and for her this 2 minis would be the same (yea I know but I love her).

        So I’m good with the 2133, but thanks for your quick reply.

        Cheers


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: